Real vs. fake

Counterfeits are everywhere, especially on high-value singles. Here’s how to spot the common ones for each game — and how to verify before you spend real money. You’ll find these same tips on every card page.

Is it real? Pokémon authenticity tips

Most fake Pokémon cards give themselves away on the back, the texture, and a light test. Compare against a card you know is genuine from the same era whenever you can.

  • Light (rosette) testHold the card up to a bright light. A genuine card is opaque — you should not see light pass through. Many fakes are printed on thinner stock and glow through.
  • Back colour & blue layerReal cards have a specific blue swirl back and a thin black core layer visible on the edge. Fakes often have an off-blue, too-dark, or washed-out back, and no dark core line on the edge.
  • Texture & holoOn holo/ultra-rare cards, feel for the textured foil and look at how the shine moves. Flat, mirror-like or grainy holo that doesn't match official patterns is a red flag.
  • Font, spacing & colourCheck the energy symbols, HP font and set symbol against a reference image. Fakes frequently have slightly wrong fonts, fuzzy text, oversaturated colours, or a misplaced set symbol.
  • Set symbol & copyrightConfirm the set symbol, card number and the copyright/date line match the real set the card is from. Mismatches (e.g. a modern card claiming a vintage set) are a giveaway.

Red flags

  • Price that's far below market for a card this valuable.
  • Seller has no grading photos, blurry images, or won't show the back.
  • “Proxy”, “custom”, “oripa”, “orica”, or “not for resale” anywhere in the listing.
  • Bulk lots of high-value cards from a brand-new or no-feedback seller.

These tips help spot common fakes but aren’t a guarantee. For expensive cards, buy from reputable sellers and consider professional grading/authentication.

Is it real? Yu-Gi-Oh! authenticity tips

Yu-Gi-Oh! authenticity hinges on the holographic seal, card stock colour, and text quality. Konami prints to tight standards, so fakes usually slip up on at least one.

  • Eye of Anubis hologramGenuine TCG cards have a small holographic seal (gold for most, silver for some promos) on the bottom-right of the front. It should shift colour cleanly. Fakes have a flat, off-colour, or missing seal.
  • Card stock & brown coreReal cards have a slightly off-white front and a darker brown/grey core visible on the edge. Bend gently — fakes are often too white, too glossy, or have a pure-white core.
  • Front colour & borderThe tan/brown card border and artwork colours should look muted and consistent. Overly bright, blue-ish, or pixelated artwork suggests a scan-and-reprint fake.
  • Font & 1st Edition textCheck the name font, ATK/DEF numbers and the set/edition code. Wrong fonts, fuzzy small text, or a set code that doesn't exist are clear signs.

Red flags

  • Price that's far below market for a card this valuable.
  • Seller has no grading photos, blurry images, or won't show the back.
  • “Proxy”, “custom”, “oripa”, “orica”, or “not for resale” anywhere in the listing.
  • Bulk lots of high-value cards from a brand-new or no-feedback seller.

These tips help spot common fakes but aren’t a guarantee. For expensive cards, buy from reputable sellers and consider professional grading/authentication.

Is it real? Magic authenticity tips

Magic uses a fine rosette dot print pattern and a distinctive card stock that counterfeits struggle to match. A jeweller's loupe is your best friend for high-value cards.

  • Rosette print patternUnder a loupe or strong magnification, real cards show a regular rosette dot pattern. Fakes often show a fuzzy, lined, or pixel-grid pattern instead.
  • Green-dot / light testHolding many genuine cards to light shows a faint green tint and a sharp blue core line on the edge. A washed-out or grey core line can indicate a fake.
  • Card stock & snapGenuine cards have a specific weight, flex and snap. Fakes tend to feel too stiff, too flimsy, too glossy, or unusually slippery.
  • Font, borders & set symbolCompare the typeface, mana symbols, set symbol and collector number with a reference. Wrong fonts, blurry text, or colour-shifted borders are red flags.

Red flags

  • Price that's far below market for a card this valuable.
  • Seller has no grading photos, blurry images, or won't show the back.
  • “Proxy”, “custom”, “oripa”, “orica”, or “not for resale” anywhere in the listing.
  • Bulk lots of high-value cards from a brand-new or no-feedback seller.

These tips help spot common fakes but aren’t a guarantee. For expensive cards, buy from reputable sellers and consider professional grading/authentication.

Guidance is educational and not a guarantee — Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic fakes keep improving. For expensive cards, buy from reputable sellers and consider professional grading.